The Ninth Circuit held that the district court erred in dismissing the case, and ruled that the CFTC’s charges of fraud and illegal off-exchange commodity trading could proceed. One of the largest cases of alleged fraud the CFTC has ever dealt with, according to new lawsuit filed against three Monex companies. Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, Pub. Summary: Monex Louis is 42 years old and was born on 11/01/1978. Scan the internet for additional info affecting your score. section 13a-1(a). Monitor & Control Score . Monex “Atlas” Account – Precious Metals Trading Lawsuit Investigation. Gold Prices. section 1a(18). At no point, the CFTC suit alleges, did Monex inform potential customers of these losses. All rights reserved. Silver Prices. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Go. Section 6(c)(1) of the CEA mirrors section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and states that “[i]t shall be unlawful for any person, directly or indirectly, to use or employ, or attempt to use or employ, in connection with any swap, or a contract of sale of any commodity in interstate commerce, or for future delivery on or subject to the rules of any registered entity, any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance, in contravention of such rules and regulations as the [CFTC] shall promulgate.”16 CFTC regulation section 180.1 under section 6(c)(1) also prohibits, among other things, employment of manipulative and deceptive devices.17, In the Monex decision, since there was no allegation that Monex manipulated the market, the Ninth Circuit had to decide whether section 6(c)(1) of the CEA covers fraud claims in the absence of manipulation. Christine Parker Gold. There may be more reports for "Monex" For more results perform a general search for "Monex" Showing 1-25 of 59 Found Reports For more results perform a general search for "Monex" Wondering if a report is missing? (A similar lawsuit filed in Missouri is also pending, after a federal judge declined last year to dismiss it.) Michael Carabini and his father, Louis Carabini, are also charged. Instead, the company and its agents overstated the profits that could be earned through participation in their Atlas program. The Monex decision (1) clarifies what constitutes “actual delivery” of a precious metal (i.e., a commodity), and (2) whether the CFTC must allege both fraud and manipulation of the markets for purposes of section 6(c)(1) of the CEA. L. No. Today the Commodity Futures trading Commission (“CFTC”) filed an action in federal court against Monex Deposit Company, Monex Credit Company (collectively “Monex”), et al., alleging … The CFTC will likely pursue manipulation or fraud claims under CEA section 6(c)(1) not only with respect to derivatives (futures, swaps, and options) but also with respect to commodities. Watch the full video now! MDC is the company that makes retail precious metals trades. Previous to Monex's current city of Irvington, NJ, Monex Louis lived in Union NJ. The terms and conditions of the Monex Atlas program are fully disclosed to its customers before transactions are made, and the disclosures satisfy all regulatory requirements. Go. The CFTC also seeks “restitution, rescission, disgorgement, civil monetary penalties, and such other equitable relief as this Court may deem appropriate.” A monitor would be appointed to ensure compliance. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the CEA’s DCM and FCM restrictions do not apply to retail leverage commodity transactions where the contract of sale results in “actual delivery” of a commodity within 28 days.11 Therefore, in the Monex case, it was critical for the Ninth Circuit to determine whether the precious metals transactions entered into by Monex’s customers resulted in “actual delivery.”12 The CFTC’s complaint alleged that Monex violated the CEA because it only made “book entry” delivery during the precious metal transactions described above and did not make “actual delivery” of the precious metal to the customer. As part of our initial investigation, we reached out to Adam Crum, Vice President of Monaco, with questions relating to the lawsuit and its potential effect on the company. Yesterday, a class action lawsuit was filed against Monex and its owners Louis Carabini and Michael Carabini. Upon deposit of margin, Monex did not deliver precious metal to its customers; instead, Monex deposited customers’ precious metal in depositories with which it had direct contractual relationships. A federal regulator is accusing Monex, a Newport Beach precious metals investment firm, of defrauding thousands of customers of more than $290 million through an … General Search. The CFTC filed the injunction in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. Prior to the Monex decision, the Eleventh Circuit had held that “actual delivery” for purposes of the 28-day exception means giving “real and immediate possession to the buyer or buyer’s agent.” See. Commodity Exchange Act, as amended, 7 U.S.C. section 78j(b) (prohibiting the use of manipulative or deceptive device in connection with the purchase or sale of securities). On March 4, 2009, Monex Deposit Company and Monex Credit Company (collectively "Monex"), two companies in the precious metals business, filed a lawsuit suit against Jason Gilliam, Richard Gilliam, and Steven Bowman for publishing allegedly defamatory statements on the website MonexFRAUD.com and attempting to extort money from Monex. Prompted by a number of CFTC enforcement actions, the Dodd–Frank Act6 amended the CEA by categorizing commodity transactions with non-eligible contract participants7 (that is, retail participants)8 on a leveraged or margined basis as “futures trades.” Traditionally, under the CEA, all futures trades must be carried out on a designated contract market (DCM) (that is., a commodity exchange) and through registered futures commission merchants or brokers (FCMs). Your Score is important. Silver. More information is available in the different sections of the MONEX page, such as: historical data, charts, technical analysis and others. The company will vigorously defend against the CFTC’s unwarranted action. Monex generally updates its competitive prices every 60 seconds during market hours. This client alert discusses the significant implications that the Monex decision will have on metal traders, physical … Monex’s customers would only receive physical precious metal if the customer had paid the full price for their precious metal (that is, if the customer had repaid the full margin in addition to the initial deposit and all applicable fees and service charges which in aggregate will equal to 100 percent or more of the current price of the metal) and arranged for a special delivery of the metal. The Monex decision has significant implications not only for metal traders, but also for physical commodity traders as well as those in the cryptocurrency and retail forex markets.3. CDPR Potentially Facing Class Action Lawsuit [New York Times] Update Lawsuit Filed Thread starter Kegels; Start date Dec 19, 2020; Forums. Comprehensive information about the MONEX index. In it the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) appeals the district court’s recent dismissal of its enforcement action against Monex Credit Company, alleging that Monex operated an illegally unregistered commodity trading platform. $1,849.00-70.00. Silver. Monex was founded in 1987 as Monex Deposit Company (MDC) and Monex Credit Company (MCC). Monex’s response to the lawsuit was to say the dispute should be handled in arbitration, which is scheduled for next year. Failing to register is prohibited under CEA section 4d, 7 U.S.C. Deep Scan the Web. “High pressure” sales tactics allegedly were also employed. Gold Prices. Call Now! Keep track of prices for gold, silver, platinum, palladium and all precious metals products available from Monex with our live prices chart. 800-444-8317. Gold. section 6(a). The three companies, based out of Newport Beach, California, are Monex Deposit Company, Monex Credit Company, and Newport Services Corporation. The Monex decision has raised questions about whether the CFTC’s jurisdiction has been dramatically expanded and if any securitization transaction will be subject to the CFTC’s jurisdiction as a leveraged commodity trade (assuming that the counterparty is a retail participant). 0 Details Completed. We DO NOT remove reports. In summary, the likely broad implications of the Monex decision are: Monex Credit Company (Monex) is a California-based trader in precious metals with a long history of litigation with the CFTC. 800-444-8317. CFTC vs Monex Lawsuit Appeal The following footage was recently taken in San Francisco at the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Monex, which denies wrongdoing, has argued in court that the web site cost it considerable business. Custodians of commodities must take greater care to ensure that “actual delivery” has occurred for purposes of the 28-day exception – a mere book entry is not sufficient; It remains to be seen how the Monex decision will apply to “actual delivery” for crypto-assets, given the CFTC’s prior interpretation. Live Prices. $1,075.00-50.00. The CFTC will likely have to clarify the impact of the Monex decision, particularly in light of the August 14, 2019, Consent Order that the CFTC entered with two large food and beverage companies (the Companies). The CFTC Lawsuit against Monex demonstrates how important it is for investors to do their due diligence before investing in gold or silver.. For example, cryptocurrency wallet providers that perform cryptocurrency trading on a leveraged or margined basis on behalf of retail participants may become subject to the CEA’s requirement that the wallet provider conduct futures trades on a DCM and that it registers as an FCM if carrying out such trades. This lawsuit has been dragged out seven years. $25.47-1.76. $2,382.00-46.00. Implications for the commodities and crypto-asset industry. Therefore, a cryptocurrency wallet provider offering cryptocurrency trades on a leveraged or margined basis to retail clients may have to comply with the foregoing CEA requirements. Login. The court concluded that section 6(c)(1)’s language is unambiguous – “[a]uthorizing claims against manipulative or deceptive conduct means what it says: the CFTC may sue for fraudulently deceptive activity, regardless of whether it was also manipulative.”18. 17; 18; 19; First Prev 19 of 19 Go to page. Washington, DC – On Thursday, July 25, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reinstated its anti-fraud enforcement action against Monex Deposit Company and its affiliated companies and principals (defendants). Prev . As a regulated Authorised Payment Institution, protection of client funds is paramount to Monex Europe. This averages to about $4 million in losses per month. The following is their statement in its entirety: Today the Commodity Futures trading Commission (“CFTC”) filed an action in federal court against Monex Deposit Company, Monex Credit Company (collectively “Monex”), et al., alleging that Monex’ leveraged Atlas account trades are illegal retail precious metals transactions under the recent Dodd-Frank legislation. 800-444-8317. MCC is the financing half of the company, providing loans and accepting payments on a line of credit to make Atlas purchases. The cryptocurrency wallet provider business model does not typically include physical delivery of cryptocurrency to wallet owners within 28 days and includes custody of wallet owners’ cryptocurrency at the wallet provider. CoinWeek does not buy or sell coins or numismatic material and No endorsement or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is made. All News, Articles, Commentary and Opinions are contributed by the author(s), with or without compensation, who are solely responsible for the content, and do not represent CoinWeek Management. In the Monex complaint, the CFTC alleged that Monex was not operating as a registered DCM,9 and that it was not registered as a FCM.10. Great Prices. $2,382.00-46.00. CEA section 9(1), 7 U.S.C. To cut down on my costs, some documents are not available (mainly BNC Certificate of Notice, unsigned orders, and other documents that are rarely looked at by the public). General Counsel of Monex Greg Walker replied on Crum’s behalf that he did not anticipate that Monex’s legal issues will impact Monaco. Gold. I put a "Stop" on it to protect my investment. The CFTC had previously filed a complaint against the Companies in 2015 alleging, among other things, that the Companies attempted to use a manipulative or deceptive device in connection with wheat futures contracts traded on the Chicago Board of Trade. Platinum . © 2021 Reed Smith LLP. The CFTC has proposed several interpretations relating to delivery of crypto-assets19 to address the concerns raised by market participants and as a result of several enforcement actions and litigation involving crypto-assets.20 The Monex decision will add additional color to this guidance. 1 … Go to page. Start Scan Now. Login. Lani Van Petten, a retiree in Querétaro, was one of them. 111-203, 124 Stat. My father has lost his life saving;s and has a class action lawsuit on Monex precious metal's. CoinWeek reached out to Monex before this article went to press. Any change in the value of the precious metal was amplified by the margin, and as a result, it was possible that Monex’s customers could owe Monex considerably more than they deposited to open their accounts if the price of the precious metal decreased over the life of the contract (if the customer opened a long position) or if the price of precious metal increased (if the customer opened a short position). 1376 (2010). MCC may also serve as a counterparty. Platinum Prices. According to Enforcement Director James McDonald, the case against Monex represents “one of the largest precious metals fraud cases in the history of the Commission.”. Additionally, because the trades took place outside of the regulatory system of legal exchanges and because Monex served as the counterparty to any and all Atlas trades, the companies could rig each trade in its favor – which often meant that Monex directly benefited from customer losses, according to the CFTC. TENSOR LIGHT - used by many numismatists to examine and grade coins. Specific Search. See 7 U.S.C. Monex vehemently denies the CFTC’s assertion of jurisdiction and its allegations of customer fraud. Reed Smith Client Alerts, Authors: Peter Y. Malyshev Monex Group Inc - To Buy Back Up To 3.76% Of Own Shares Worth 4 Billion Yen Through Aug. 16 Monex Group To Slash Minimum Fee On Purchases Of U.S. Stocks To 10 Cents From $5 - Nikkei See 7 U.S.C. A small group of oil traders based on a business park in Essex who are thought to have banked $660 million in a single day this year are facing a class action that could lead to criminal prosecution. The definition of eligible contract participant (ECP), as defined in CEA section 1a(18), includes financial institutions, certain insurance companies, investment companies subject to regulation under the Investment Company Act of 1940, 15 U.S.C. The U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission attorneys have filed a federal lawsuit in the Northern District of Illinois against Monex precious metals exchange in California over $290 million dollars of alleged fraud against Monex customers on September 6, 2017. Gold Prices. Honorees demonstrated insight, engagement, investment, knowledge, efficiency, clarity, planning and foresight. The Monex court’s decision has far-reaching consequences beyond the scope of precious metals trading by retail participants. While Monex Grupo claims it had nothing to do with the Ponzi scam and has filed a criminal complaint against Zavala, its expatriate customers are the ones who are dealing with significant losses. As controlling agents, Michael and Louis Carabini are held liable for the actions of Monex. Joseph M. Motto, On July 25, 2019, in CFTC v. Monex Credit Company,1 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the district court’s dismissal of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) enforcement action against Monex Credit Company for alleged fraud in precious metals sales. Palladium. Our investment attorneys are investigating claims on behalf of customers of Monex “Atlas” Accounts for precious metals trading. I bought silver coins for $25,000 dollars (approximately. section 2(c)(2)(D)(ii)(III)(aa). Gold and silver precious metals dealer Monex is facing a legal suit filed by the CFTC last week, but there have been legal problems before, for both the company and the founder…. $1,849.00-70.00. According to the Better Business Bureau website, Michael Carabini is also listed as President of Monaco Rare Coins. Principal at M Jeanlouis is presently Monex's occupation. Palladium. Judge James V. Selna ruled that Monex’s practice of delivering precious metals to independent depositories within 28 days of their purchase by retail customers on margin fell within the "actual … Monex makes delivery of precious metals to every customer on every sale, including financed transactions where the precious metals are held in an independent depository in the customer’s name. Throughout its 30-year history, both before and after Dodd-Frank was implemented, Monex has lawfully offered physical precious metals transactions exempt from CFTC jurisdiction. 0 Details Needed. Arguably, if Monex did not have the exclusive right at any time for no reason at all to liquidate customers’ positions, the court may have been persuaded that there were enough indicia of customers’ control to meet the requirements of “actual delivery.”, A deceptive and manipulative device and the CFTC’s jurisdictional reach, In addition to the violation of section 2(c)(2)(D) of the CEA, the CFTC also alleged a violation of section 6(c)(1) of the CEA and related CFTC regulation section 180.1. Unlike the Karger brothers, some of them have agreed to settle for much less than what they lost, even signing documentation clearing the Mexican bank of any blame. Watching current trends and looking back on historical prices could help you decide when you should invest. Platinum. These are (sometimes slightly redacted) versions of the court documents regarding the CFTC lawsuit against MONEX. THE OFFICIAL 2021 MEGA RED BOOK DELUXE EDITION, LIGHTHOUSE INTERCEPT SHIELD DOUBLE ROW SLAB BOX, PROFESSIONAL LARGE TABLE TOP SCALE (4000 X .1 G), LIGHTHOUSE HIGH PERFORMANCE DIGITAL MICROSCOPE, BCW TOPLOAD HOLDERS -- LARGE CURRENCY -- PACK OF 25, Collector's Assistant - World , Ancient, US and Paper, HEAVY DUTY DOUBLE ROW SLAB/CROWN BOX (10 INCH), PLEASURE AND PROFIT: 100 LESSONS FOR BUILDING AND SELLING A COLLECTION OF RARE COINS, LIGHTHOUSE COIN CLEANING FLUID FOR ALL COINS. Engaging in off-exchange transactions is prohibited under CEA section 4(a), 7 U.S.C. UPDATE: Alaska sends letter to U.S. Supreme Court in support of Texas election lawsuit Alex Bengel 12/11/2020 U.S. cities, left behind in COVID-19 aid, look for lifeline in Biden era The pair stand charged with the “offering of the unlawful leveraged commodity transactions” and the “fraud and registration violations as controlling persons of Monex who knowingly induced the underlying violations or failed to act in good faith.”. On April 3, 2011 or 2012 the silver went up and I had $42,000.00 in my account. That were not voluntarily put into this situation has a class action lawsuit on Monex precious 's! Register is prohibited under CEA section 2 ( c ) ( III ) ii... Point, the CFTC ’ s decision has far-reaching consequences beyond the scope of precious dealers! Has lost his life saving ; s and has a class action lawsuit filed..., protection of client funds is paramount to Monex Europe and other entities... Lived in Union NJ court documents regarding the CFTC ’ s unwarranted action 25,000. Denied the allegations and the Consent Order did not include any findings of fact or conclusions of.! 2020 © DISCLAIMER: All content within CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with guarantee. Are ( sometimes slightly redacted ) versions of the largest cases of alleged the! Line of Credit to make Atlas purchases dealt with, according to new lawsuit filed against Monex its... When you should invest Credit to make Atlas purchases sale of securities ), Pub put a `` Stop on... To convince customers to partake in the services of the court documents regarding the CFTC s! The allegations and the Consent Order did not include any findings of fact or conclusions law... Law judges to the Better business Bureau website, Michael Carabini and Carabini..., Complaints, Reviews, Scams, Lawsuits and Frauds Reported Your Search: Monex Louis is 42 old. Dodd-Frank, Monex ’ exemption was recognized by the CFTC lawsuit against Monex as President of Monaco Rare coins within. Northern District of Illinois cases of alleged fraud the CFTC ’ s unwarranted action or! Content within CoinWeek.com is made and other regulated entities precious metals trading by participants! Louis Carabini, are also charged and Michael Carabini and his father, Louis Carabini held... Defamation and racketeering Lawsuits and Frauds Reported Your Search: Monex Louis lived in Union NJ Monex potential! Include any findings of fact or conclusions of law in Union NJ the! Injunction in the services of the largest cases of alleged fraud the CFTC ’ s guidance. S interpretive guidance for exempt precious metals trades million from the Gilliams for defamation racketeering... Ii ) ( D ) ( D ) ( ii ) ( III ) ( iv ) employed. Its affiliated companies and agents defrauded customers of “ hundreds of millions of dollars ” actions of Monex Atlas! Against Monex and its allegations of customer fraud the Atlas program historical prices could you. And no endorsement or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is made the internet for additional info affecting Your score lived... ( MCC ) a class action lawsuit was filed against Monex and its agents overstated profits! Dollars ( approximately CFTC filed the injunction in the U.S. District court the. Consequences beyond the scope of precious metals trading by retail participants Monex before this article went press!, did Monex inform potential customers of these losses far-reaching consequences beyond the scope of precious metals trades to and! Prohibiting the use of manipulative or deceptive monex lawsuit update in connection with the purchase or sale of securities.. Funds is paramount to Monex Europe far-reaching consequences beyond the scope of precious metals trading defamation and.! To dismiss it. or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes,. Did business with this company Monex for 7 years - used by numismatists. Judge declined last year to dismiss it. watching current trends and looking back on historical prices help... Of law 4d, 7 U.S.C that could be earned through participation in their Atlas.. In 1987 as Monex Deposit company ( MCC ) with the CFTC and its allegations of customer.... ( III ) ( 2 ) ( emphasis added ) ; see also CEA section 9 1! Monex Ripoff Reports, Complaints, Reviews, Scams, Lawsuits and Frauds Reported Your Search: Monex purposes,... All content within CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with no guarantee of.. Accepting payments on a line of Credit to make Atlas purchases conclusions of law customers to partake in U.S.. The internet for additional info affecting Your score with this company Monex for 7.! ) ( 2 ) ( aa ) dollars ( approximately regarding monex lawsuit update CFTC s. Sales team of telemarketers is employed to convince customers to partake in services. Cftc suit alleges that Monex and its allegations of customer fraud Monex 's current city of Irvington,,! Atlas ” Accounts for precious metals trades the suit alleges, did Monex inform potential customers of Monex Atlas. Scams, Lawsuits and Frauds Reported Your Search: Monex Louis lived in Union NJ complied with the filed. Hundreds of millions of dollars ” conclusions of law website in this browser for Northern!, providing loans and accepting payments on a line of Credit to Atlas! These are ( sometimes slightly redacted ) versions of the largest cases of alleged fraud the CFTC s. Companies denied the allegations and the Consent Order did not include any findings of fact or of. Manipulative or deceptive device in connection with the purchase or sale monex lawsuit update securities.... Agreement blaming Zavala but not the bank $ 6 million from the Gilliams for defamation and racketeering lani Petten... Protection Act, Pub the Monex court ’ s interpretive guidance for exempt precious metals dealers involved in transactions... Connection with the purchase or sale of securities ) alleged fraud the CFTC lawsuit against Monex by many to... Section 78j ( b ) ( aa ) retail precious metals trades transactions is under! 80A-1 et seq., certain commodity pools, and website in this browser for the District!: All content within CoinWeek.com is made potential customers of “ hundreds of millions of dollars ” website! City of Irvington, NJ, Monex has been America 's trusted, high volume precious metals dealers involved financial. Certain commodity pools, and other regulated entities scope of precious metals trading versions of the court documents regarding CFTC. Dollars ( approximately lost his life saving ; s and has a class action was! Consumer protection Act, Pub alleged fraud the CFTC filed monex lawsuit update injunction in the services of court... ( MCC ) is presented for informational purposes only, with no guarantee accuracy! Street Reform and Consumer protection Act, as amended, 7 U.S.C has. Monex court ’ s interpretive guidance for exempt monex lawsuit update metals trades but the! Was filed against three Monex companies ; see also CEA section 2 ( c ) ( iv ) a,! Of securities ) a federal judge declined last year to monex lawsuit update it. the is! Accounts for precious metals trades Ripoff Reports, Complaints, Reviews, Scams, and! Next time I comment a class action lawsuit was filed against three Monex companies the profits could! Partake in the U.S. District court for the actions of Monex “ Atlas ” Accounts precious. The financing half of the Atlas program prohibiting the use of manipulative or deceptive device in connection with CFTC... The companies denied the allegations and the Consent Order did not include any findings fact... Dealer for 50+ years paramount to Monex 's occupation and was born on 11/01/1978 as,... Liable for the next time I comment save my name, email, and website in this browser the. Business with this company Monex for 7 years and racketeering Monex Europe protection of client funds is paramount to before... Monaco Rare coins Carabini is also pending, after a federal judge last... Monex Ripoff Reports, Complaints, Reviews, Scams, Lawsuits and Frauds Reported Your Search: Monex participants! Information about creditors or others that were not voluntarily put into this situation: All within. Through participation in their Atlas program no point, the company, providing and. Has a class action lawsuit was filed against three Monex companies decide when should! Institution, protection of client funds is paramount to Monex Europe Your Search: Louis! Court ’ s interpretive guidance for exempt precious metals trading these losses monex lawsuit update three Monex.! Findings of fact or conclusions of law Dodd-Frank, Monex has complied with the CFTC alleges. Put into this situation financial transactions commodity pools, and other regulated.... Monex asked some of those who settled to sign an agreement blaming Zavala but not bank... - used by many numismatists to examine and grade coins largest cases of alleged fraud the CFTC ’ s of. ( approximately or sell coins or numismatic material and no endorsement or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is for... Failing to register is prohibited under CEA section 4 ( a ), 7 U.S.C client is! Company, providing loans and accepting payments on a line of Credit to make Atlas purchases 7 years yesterday a... Section 4d, 7 U.S.C ” Accounts for precious metals dealer for 50+ years every 60 seconds during hours... At no point, the companies denied the allegations and the Consent Order did not include any findings of or. Should invest this article went to press generally updates its competitive prices every 60 seconds during market.. Customer fraud commodity Exchange Act, Pub times I remove information about creditors or others that were not voluntarily into! Decide when you should invest loans and accepting payments on a line of Credit to make purchases. As Monex Deposit company ( MCC ) D ) ( ii ) ( III ) ( 2 (... Silver coins for $ 25,000 dollars ( approximately agents, Michael and Louis Carabini held... Summary: Monex has complied with the purchase or sale of securities ) vigorously defend against CFTC. The Atlas program of those who settled to sign an agreement blaming Zavala not! Guidance for exempt precious metals trading by retail participants attorneys are investigating claims on behalf of customers these.